Week 71: is the Pirc Defense good for beginners? A 3–4 week with it

After nine days without a game, I came back on June 2, 2025, and played 19 rapid games in a week: 10 wins and 9 losses, rating 1252 → 1260 (+8). As Black I leaned on the same family of openings as always, the Pirc and the Modern, and they went 3–4. That makes this a good week to ask a question beginners often search: is the Pirc Defense good for beginners? My honest answer from these games is that it's fine, and that it wasn't the reason I won or lost.

The week in numbers

With Black I scored 6 wins and 4 losses; with White, 4 wins and 5 losses. The White losses included another Englund Gambit, game 1511 against Rotobono (1305), where I once again answered 1.d4 e5 with 2.c3. That's three Englund games in a row with the same move, and three losses.

Is the Pirc Defense good for beginners? What my week says

Here are my seven Pirc and Modern games as Black. The Geller System (White plays Nf3 and Bc4 early) went 2–1: wins against loxyaea (1224) and praktak (1236), a loss to Strouer (1270). The two Modern games split 1–1, a loss to CorreitaEsp (1286) at 90.3% accuracy and a win against nancycihine (1265). The two other Pirc games, against Constantine1961 (1284) and Paidjoe13 (1271), were losses. My other three Black games, an East Indian, a Nimzowitsch and an East Indian London, were all wins.

So the Pirc didn't give me an edge. But when I look at how the games were decided, it wasn't opening knowledge. The setup is easy to remember: pawn to d6, knight to f6, pawn to g6, bishop to g7, castle. What the Pirc asks of a beginner is patience, because White gets the center and you have to wait for the right moment to hit back. My first key moment shows the opposite problem: when the moment came, I grabbed the wrong thing.

Moment 1: the automatic recapture

Game 1498 against loxyaea (1224), Black, Pirc Geller System (game). White had just taken on c5 with a pawn, and I was winning, −3.52.

. . . r . r k .
p p . . . p b p
. . q p p . p .
. . P . n . . .
. . P . P N . .
. . P . . . . P
P . . Q . P P .
. R B R . . K .

Recapturing felt natural. But Qxe4 was much stronger: my queen takes a central pawn and attacks three things, the rook on b1 (no defender), the pawn on c4 (no defender) and the knight on f4. My pawn recapture instead opened the d-file, and White's queen took my rook on d8. The evaluation went from −3.52 to 0.00. I still won the game by resignation on move 44, because White blundered later. The lesson: when your opponent captures, a recapture is one option, not an obligation.

Moment 2: the knight that went too far

Game 1499 against AS_Prayoga (1277), White, Old Benoni (game).

r . . q r . k .
. b . p n p b p
p . . B p . p .
. . . . . . . .
Q . N . . . . .
. . P . P N . .
P P . . . P P P
R . . . . R K .

Nb6 attacks a rook, which looks good, but Black's queen can simply take the knight, and from b6 the queen attacks my b2 pawn and my bishop on d6 at the same time. The engine went from +0.76 to −6.58. AS_Prayoga took a different route, but I was worse from then on and lost. Rfd1, a quiet rook move, kept a small edge.

Moment 3: the discovered attack I didn't see

Game 1500 against LULU0117 (1228), White, Krause Variation (game). Black's rook had just moved from f6 to f8.

. . . . . r k .
r p . b b . p .
. p n . p . B p
. . . p . p . .
. . . P . B . N
P . . . P . . .
. P . . . P P P
R . . . . R K .

The rook on f6 had been blocking the diagonal from Black's bishop on e7 to my knight on h4. When the rook moved, the bishop suddenly attacked the knight, a discovered attack, and nothing defended it. I played b4 on the other side of the board and lost the knight: +0.04 to −5.45. Then came one of the strangest wins of my journey: I kept playing, Black kept giving chances back, and on move 83 I mated with Qa4# with my clock at 0 seconds.

The lesson of the week

All three moments are about the same habit: after every move by my opponent, ask what changed. In game 1498 a capture changed the files; in game 1500 a rook moving away opened a diagonal; in game 1499 my own knight moved to a square where it could be taken. The Pirc is a fine opening for a beginner, but no opening protects you from not looking at what the last move did.

And for the third week running, the Englund Gambit: next time I'll take the pawn.

All games this week

Previous: week 70 · Next: week 72 · Hub: /journey/ · Want the "what changed?" moments of your own games pointed out? AI chess analysis with Chess Coach.